Skip to content
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
NexusClub

Which Players Have Earned a Spot in Troy's Premier League Weekly Best XI?

In the wake of every batch of Premier League matches this season, BBC football analyst Troy Deeney selects his team and gaffer of the week.

Here are the most recent picks. What are your thoughts? Share your views.

The Last Line of Defense

Jordan Pickford (Everton): One of the key play in Everton's resounding victory against the Blues came from his superb save to deny Enzo Fernandez. Pickford has stepped up when it counts in such moments for his club this season and, the expectation is, he can continue for England during the World Cup. Just last week, he made a costly mistake versus Arsenal but has since recovered admirably to produce for the Toffees.

Defensive Unit

Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest): It was a massive pivotal match for Forest away at Tottenham, with Premier League status at stake for each team. And Williams produced a massive showing to help his side secure a critical victory in the relegation fight. He provided two assists, producing when it mattered most.

Matty Cash (Aston Villa): I did not think West Ham posed a major threat going forward but Cash was solid and maintained organization for Villa. He managed to just keeping the play moving. He offered a lot in an attacking sense and was also able to neutralize everything the Hammers offered in attack.

James Tarkowski (Everton): It constituted yet another solid display from the Everton centre-back. He demonstrated his experience and control, and was always in the right place. He made important interventions when required and, significantly, served as a reassuring figure in their defense. How Chelsea crave a centre-back with that kind of gumption, particularly given the unconvincing defending they have exhibited at times.

Central Park

Chris Rigg (Sunderland): It amounted to a solid display from Rigg in a memorable Tyne-Wear derby. He did not do anything extraordinary against Newcastle but he performed all his duties exceptionally competently. With Rigg, you understand exactly what to expect from him.

James Garner (Everton): He could have relaxed on the back of getting called up to the Three Lions team recently. But instead, he got on with it and put in a superb shift. It was a exquisite pass from him to Beto for Everton's first goal. Having played with him at Watford, I can confirm he's all about non-stop running and physical presence. He is the complete package and I am confident he performs for England to play his way into that World Cup squad.

John McGinn (Aston Villa): He's their skipper, leader and key figure. It's amounted to a pair of enormous displays in the space of a week from him. Villa can be considered a good side. But McGinn makes them a top one. If they are going to secure the top five and compete for the European title, they depend on him to continue performing at this standard.

Harry Wilson (Fulham): He has cultivated a habit of scoring important goals and he did exactly that once more in the latest round. I ponder how the club will find a replacement if he chooses to move on. They are not going to pay a fortune on somebody with what he offers. They desperately want him to sign a new deal as he is a hugely key component of that Cottagers set-up.

The Forwards

Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United): It feels like the Portuguese playmaker is becoming a staple in the weekly best XI. You must select him once again after a further goal, and additionally forcing the James Hill own goal. How long will United stay average and keep him before he decides it is the right moment to depart the club?

Beto (Everton): On this occasion, we have two forwards who are at opposite points in their professional journey. I am not sure Beto is a lasting solution for Everton's goalscoring issues, but manager David Moyes is getting the best out of him right now. It is impressive given how ineffective he was in the initial months.

Danny Welbeck (Brighton): He was overlooked by Thomas Tuchel again for the England team, at a point when they need cover to skipper Harry Kane. But Welbeck continued to perform for the Seagulls with a brace, to overcome title holders Liverpool, and bring his total to twelve goals for the season.

Manager of the Week

David Moyes (Everton): The fixture between Everton and Chelsea was a perfect example of old school against new school. Chelsea's manager Liam Rosenior is continuing to carve his path at the outset of his managerial journey but Moyes devised a perfect gameplan to claim a convincing victory. The Toffees were more assertive and more robust in each area of the game and it was a enormous win for them.

What's your verdict with Troy's picks? Which players would make up your Team of the Week? Have your say.

KY
By

Karen Young

Elara is a software engineer and tech writer passionate about open-source projects and digital innovation.

NexusClub

Type to search articles.